Smileline
Marketing

Reviews

Reply to Google reviews, request patient feedback, and route private feedback to your team.

Open SEO → Reviews. Reviews combines first-party patient feedback with Google review monitoring and replies. Reviews isn't on the free SEO & Social plan: it needs the full system.

Owners and managers can configure the feature. The front desk can read reviews, send a request, recover private feedback and respond. Analysts see aggregate results without patient-level or reviewer-level detail. Telesales have no access.

Read the page at a glance

Review requests, across the top, follows this month's requests from visit to review (months follow your practice's time zone). An On or Off badge shows whether automatic requests are switched on. It has five steps:

  1. Visits done — the visits marked done this month, in your practice management system or in Smileline. This is the moment that sends an automatic request.
  2. Asked — the review requests sent this month, including those sent with Ask for a review, and how many went by WhatsApp, SMS and email.
  3. Opened — how many of those patients opened the review link, and the share of those asked.
  4. Went to Google — the patient opened Google's review page. This is not proof they left a review.
  5. Private feedback — the patient left private feedback instead.

Below the steps, Smileline says how many visits done this month got no request — for example the patient had no marketing consent on any channel, is under 18, was asked recently, or the visit's type is one you skip. A visit whose request is still waiting to go out is counted in neither number.

All requests opens every request and Settings opens the request settings. When something stops requests from going out — a channel with no provider, a missing message, no Google location — an amber box lists it, with Fix in Settings.

Below that, the page has two columns. On the left, Google reviews lists your reviews, newest first, each with its stars, the reviewer, when it was left, and Needs a reply or Replied. Choose which reviews to show at the top of the list:

  • Needs a reply — the reviews with no reply yet, with how many there are.
  • All — every review (the list the page opens on).
  • 1–3 stars — the reviews of three stars or fewer.

Each choice applies across every page of reviews.

The right column holds three cards:

  • The rating card — the rating and review count Google Maps search results last showed for your practice, how far that count moved over the last 12 weeks (for example +14 since 3 Aug), and when your practice was last seen there. The change is not a count of new reviews: a review taken down, or a count Google had not updated yet, moves it too.
  • Nearby practices — you and the nearby practices that showed most often in the location's latest Google Maps results (up to five), with each one's latest rating and review count. A practice missing from this week's results keeps its last figures; one not seen at all shows —.
  • Private feedback — how many patients need a call back (open recovery tasks). Open lists the private feedback.

The rating and nearby practices come from the map grid scans in Search visibility: your practice's own listing on each scan, and each tracked competitor's weekly snapshot. They fill in once a map grid scan has found your practice. They are what Google Maps search displayed, not your Google review totals: Smileline never adds up cached review content, so there is no star breakdown.

When more than one location has Google Maps results, choose a location from the menu at the top of the page. The Google Maps figures follow it; requests and reviews stay practice-wide.

Ask for a review, at the top of the page, sends a request to a patient.

All requests, Private feedback and Settings open as panels on the right of the page, so the reviews stay in view. A link that opens one (for example from a notification) opens the page with that panel.

What an analyst sees

Analysts see the numbers only. Review requests shows its five steps without the On/Off badge, its buttons or the amber box. In place of the reviews, the left column shows You vs competitors — your rating or review count week by week, for up to 12 weeks, against the nearby practices (choose Reviews or Rating) — and Review requests by month, the requests sent in each of the last 12 months and how many of their patients opened the review link or left feedback. The right column shows the same cards without their buttons.

Configure requests

First connect Google and enable at least one location — see Google profile. Requests cannot be switched on until one enabled location exists.

Then choose Settings in Review requests at the top of the page. The switch at the top turns automatic requests on and off. Below it, seven numbered steps follow a request in the order the patient receives it:

  1. A visit is marked done — an automatic request starts when a visit is marked done: in your practice management system (Smileline picks it up from the sync), or in Smileline's diary, the patient record or Leads. Booking a visit never sends anything. Under Ask after these visit types, untick the visit types that should not get a request, such as emergencies or extractions. Every type is ticked to begin with, new visit types are included until you untick them, and a visit with no type is always included. Requests you send with Ask for a review are not affected.
  2. Wait, then ask — how long after the visit the request goes, from immediately to 72 hours (two hours by default). The line below shows your quiet hours; Change quiet hours edits them. See Quiet hours.
  3. Check in first — start automatic SMS and WhatsApp requests with a short check-in, and ask for the review once the patient replies. See Check in first.
  4. On the first channel the patient can receive — which of WhatsApp, SMS and email to use, and in what order. A patient whose record names a preferred contact method gets that channel first when it is switched on and they can receive it; otherwise Smileline goes down your order, skipping any channel the patient has no consent on. Each channel row shows its messages: a Review request message for every channel, plus a Reminder when reminders are on — or, with Check in first on, a Check-in for SMS and WhatsApp instead of the reminder. A message still to choose is marked needed. See Languages for the language line under the channels.
  5. Remind once — one optional reminder to patients who have not replied, from 24 hours to 14 days after the first request (72 hours by default). While Check in first is on, reminders go by email only.
  6. Follow up on low ratings — the private rating, from one to five stars (three by default), at or below which private feedback opens a recovery task for your team. It never changes whether a patient can choose Google.
  7. Don't ask again too soon — the cooldown before the same patient is asked again, from 30 to 365 days (180 days by default).

Settings shows exactly what is still missing before requests can be switched on — naming each missing message — and lists it before you save rather than after. Changes stay in the panel if you close it before saving; Save changes keeps them, Discard drops them.

Quiet hours

Quiet hours are the days and hours during which automated messages may send. Review requests respect this window on every channel, email included. It is the practice-wide send window, so changing it here affects every automation, not only review requests, and it saves on its own with Save quiet hours. Each day's window must be at least one hour long, so a held message can't miss it.

Languages

Choose the language in Messages in, under the channels. Smileline writes to a patient in the language on their record, and uses the default when the record does not say. Only the default language's messages are required.

Switch Also send in on to add the second language. A patient whose record names a language you have not configured gets the default-language message rather than being skipped. Switching the second language off unlinks its messages when you save; the message templates themselves are untouched.

WhatsApp requests use an approved template.

Automatic requests are considered marketing messages. Smileline checks the patient's current channel preference and provider-level blocks immediately before delivery. Review requests sent by SMS are billed like every other text, per SMS part — see Text messages.

The cooldown normally starts after the messaging provider accepts the first request. If Smileline cannot prove whether the provider accepted it, the request shows Delivery unconfirmed and is not submitted again. An exact signed delivery callback can still confirm the outcome. Possession of the still-valid patient link is also delivery evidence: opening it activates the request without a resend and starts the ordinary expiry, reminder and cooldown clocks from that access.

If the provider later confirms that the first delivery failed before the patient opened the link or a reminder was accepted, Smileline invalidates the link and reminder and releases that request's cooldown. A patient access or a successfully accepted reminder proves the invitation reached them, so a late failure for the initial message does not revoke that evidence.

Who receives an automatic request

An automatic request starts only when a visit is marked done — never when it is booked — and only for a visit whose type you haven't unticked in Ask after these visit types. Smileline considers only appointments fulfilled after review requests are switched on for that location. It does not solicit historical appointments imported from a practice-management system.

A lead whose visit is marked done becomes a patient at that moment, so they are asked like any other patient — including when their first visit arrives from your practice system already done.

A patient is excluded when they are known to be a minor, are inside the practice's reputation cooldown, have already chosen Google from an earlier request, or have opted out or been blocked on the available channels. An unknown date of birth is not treated as proof that the patient is a minor.

You can also send a request to an eligible patient with Ask for a review, without relying on an appointment. The same consent, suppression, cooldown, quiet-hours and add-on checks apply.

Check in first

A patient who has just chatted with you is more likely to leave a review. With Check in first on, an automatic request sent by SMS or WhatsApp opens with a friendly check-in from your practice, such as "Hi Sarah, how did today go?", with no link. When the patient replies, Smileline answers and asks for a review, with the review link.

Email requests, and requests sent with Ask for a review, are unchanged: they never start with a check-in.

Turn it on

Open Settings and switch on Check in first. Each SMS and WhatsApp channel you use then needs a check-in message in every language you send in, alongside its usual request message, and no longer needs a reminder message. Write check-ins in Settings → Templates — see Message templates.

  • A check-in must not contain the review link: Smileline won't accept one that includes {{reputation.feedbackLink}}.
  • On WhatsApp the check-in starts the conversation, so it must be a WhatsApp template approved by Meta, in the matching language — see WhatsApp templates and Meta approval. The answer to the patient's reply is sent inside WhatsApp's 24-hour reply window.

Keep the check-in warm and short, and don't mention reviews in it. For example:

  • "Hi {{patient.firstName}}, it's {{practice.name}} — how did your visit go today?"
  • "Ciao {{patient.firstName}}, qui {{practice.name}}: com'è andata la visita di oggi?"

What the patient receives

  1. The check-in, at the time the request would normally go (your Timing setting).
  2. An answer as soon as they reply, with the review link.
  3. No reply? Your usual request message (the Review request message in Settings) goes 24 hours after the check-in was sent.

That is the only ask: SMS and WhatsApp patients get the check-in and one review message, with no reminder. Email requests still get their reminder.

The answer

On pay-as-you-go, or with the AI Assistant add-on on the older price list, AI writes a short answer to what the patient said, in their language, and asks for a review. It never asks for a positive or five-star review, never offers anything in return and never gives clinical advice. Fixed checks and a second, independent AI check reject anything else, and the standard answer goes instead.

On the older price list without the add-on, the patient gets the standard answer: "Thank you for getting back to us, Sarah! If you have a spare moment, a quick review would really help other patients find us."

Every answer includes the review link. If WhatsApp's reply window has closed by the time the answer would go, your request message goes instead.

When a reply needs a person

If the reply is unhappy, mentions pain or a problem, or asks for a call, nobody asks the patient for a review straight away. Your team gets an urgent follow-up task and an alert that opens the chat, and your request message goes automatically 3 days later. If someone from your team has already replied in the chat, Smileline stays out of the conversation, and the request message also follows 3 days later.

Every patient is still asked: Smileline only waits, so your team can help first. It never holds the review link back from an unhappy patient, because Google doesn't allow asking only happy patients for reviews.

When the review message can't go out — for example, the provider refused it — the request in Requests says why. Click Send review link now to send your request message, with a new link if the old one has expired.

Sending hours and reporting

  • The check-in and the review message both respect Quiet hours. Alerts to your team go straight away.
  • For these requests, a request counted as sent — under Asked in Review requests and in Review requests by month — and the sent status in Requests and in the API mean the check-in went out; the review link comes later.
  • The patients who need a call back, on the Private feedback card, include the follow-up tasks from unhappy or urgent replies.

The patient experience

Each request contains an opaque link that expires after 30 days. The active feedback page follows the request's English or Italian language. The patient sees two equal, neutral choices:

  • leave a review on Google; or
  • share feedback privately with the practice.

Smileline does not show or hide the Google option based on a score. Choosing Google permanently suppresses future automated and manual review requests for that patient in the practice.

Private feedback can include a one-to-five rating and comment. A patient can keep the feedback linked for follow-up or make it anonymous to practice staff. Feedback at or below the configured threshold creates a recovery task for the next business period.

After private feedback is submitted, reopening the same unexpired link shows a completed confirmation instead of the form.

Google reviews and replies

Connecting Google, linking locations and authorising reply publishing all happen on Google profile.

New Google reviews appear in Google reviews. A permitted team member clicks Reply under a review to write a reply in place or, when the AI Assistant add-on is also enabled, Write with AI to get a draft (Write again asks for another). AI output is always a draft — the review says Drafted with AI — check before publishing — and a person must review it and click Publish reply. A review that already has a reply shows it under Your reply; Edit opens it to update or delete. If Google cannot publish a reply, Smileline keeps the attempted text in the reply box, shows safe recovery guidance, and lets the team member edit or try again. If Google holds a reply back under its review policies, Smileline says so: edit the reply, then publish it again.

To find the reviews to work on, choose Needs a reply or 1–3 stars at the top of the list.

The first Google sync of a location, or the first after its reviews went more than 29 days without a sync, fills the feed with its existing reviews without alerting you or replaying each one through outbound webhooks. After that, each new review creates one new-review notification and one webhook event, whether Google's live notification, a manual sync or the daily refresh finds it first; a repeated sync of the same review version creates neither again.

If the add-on is disabled

Existing first-party request and feedback history remains readable. The current Google feed remains visible only for as long as Google's API-content rules permit it without a refresh. Smileline stops automatic and manual requests, reminders, Google synchronization and review replies, and outstanding patient links stop accepting submissions. Reviews is included on pay-as-you-go; on the older price list it's part of the SEO & Ads add-on, which you re-enable under Settings → Billing to resume operations.

On this page